Penny Granger, a dentist from Scotland, will soon be making her seventh trip to Tristan da Cunha to do dental work for the Tristan Islanders. A story published by the BBC on July 20 explained the reasons the dedicated dentist travels every year to visit the isolated settlement.

The Tristan Islanders worked together to gather and burn harmful invasive plants, serving as a beacon to celebrate the Queen’s diamond jubilee, June 4, 2012
The Tristan Islanders worked together to gather and burn harmful invasive plants, which served as a beacon to celebrate the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee, June 4, 2012 (Photo by Diego Sideburns on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

She explained that she simply loves the people. “They are just so warm and welcoming,” she said, and she went on to say that they have an old fashioned lifestyle, where people work closely together for common goals. They fondly embrace her and her eight-year-old daughter Elika, who accompanies her mom on the long flight to Cape Town, the nine-day sea voyage to Tristan, and finally the helicopter ride into The Settlement. The child has been accompanying her mother since she was 18 months old.

Each time she comes, Dr. Granger spends about five weeks working in the community: checking for cavities, drilling and filling. Local staff, such as the dental nurse profiled in a news story in December 2016, tend to emergencies during the rest of the year. That news story, and the sources on which it was based, spelled her name as “Dr. Penelope Grainger.”

The Potato Patches is a favorite destination of the Tristan Islanders
The Potato Patches is a favorite destination for the Tristan Islanders (Photo by Brian Gratwicke on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

She discussed the island with the BBC. The people raise sheep and cattle, they grow vegetables at the Potato Patches, a gardening area a short ways from The Settlement, and they do a lot of fishing. But, she said, the lobster fishing industry is the mainstay of the economy and she opined that “the people survive well there.” A complementary report in The Times indicated that she is 50 years old.

She mentioned other facts about the 264 Islanders. She said that the entire population was evacuated to the UK in 1961 when the volcano erupted, though most of them chose to return to their island a couple years later. But they picked up a love of sweet foods during their sojourn in southern England and they took their love of sweets back to Tristan with them. With more ships now visiting the island, sugary foods are easier to obtain. They suffer from more tooth decay as a result, she said.

 

A statement by the young Nubian activist Siham Othman was widely quoted after she was arrested, along with 23 other protesters during their peaceful demonstration in Aswan early last September. She was quoted again two weeks ago in an Associated Press news report reviewing the reasons for the Nubian discontent. The writer, Hamza Hendawi, is a senior reporter for the Associated Press.

A display of a water-wheel in Old Nubia in the Aswan Museum
A display of a water-wheel in Old Nubia in the Aswan Museum (Photo by Horus3 in Flickr, Creative Commons license)

Othman told the AP that she was deeply affected by the stories of her grandfather, who was one of the Nubians expelled from Old Nubia before the closing of the Aswan High Dam flooded his village in the mid-1960s. Although he then became a sailor and traveled a lot, he only told stories to his younger family members about life in Old Nubia. “He is the one who planted the dream of return in me,” the 30-year-old said. Displays of life in Old Nubia in the Aswan Museum are probably not especially satisfying for her.

The article by Hendawi explains the reasons for the protests. Basically, the issue is that the Nubians are a separate minority ethnic group in Egypt, people who have darker skin than the majority Arab population and who speak, or used to speak, Nubian, a distinctly different language. Hendawi writes that there are an estimated 3.5 to 5 million Nubians now living in Egypt along with the other 90 million Arabic Egyptians.

A colorful Nubian house
A colorful Nubian house (Photo by Norman Walsh on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

Older Nubians still treasure their memories of life in the villages that were flooded in the 1960s: large, vividly decorated houses; fields that were deep with silt deposited by the annual floods of the River Nile; deeply-rooted bonds with the river. On holidays they put dishes in the river to watch them float away. But almost all of Old Nubia was destroyed by the Aswan High Dam which forced some 55,000 people out of their villages in 1963 and 1964 since they would soon be beneath the water of Lake Nasser.

The authorities at the time promised the Nubians that they would be provided homes in new villages north of the city of Aswan and the High Dam. However, when they attempted to move into their resettlement communities, the people discovered in some cases that their new houses were not even built, or they were much smaller than the homes that they were used to. And worst of all, they did not front on their beloved Nile River. They were miles away from the water.

Nubian protesters sitting on the Aswan to Abu Simbel highway, November 2016
Nubian protesters sitting on the Aswan to Abu Simbel highway, November 2016 (Photo from the news blog Egyptian Chronicles, Creative Commons license)

The evacuees felt deceived, according to Mohammed Dawoud, a 71-year old. Many of them moved to the cities: Aswan, Alexandria, or Cairo. But that older generation mostly accepted what had happened—they tended to believe the stories of the government that the huge dam was built to benefit all Egyptians. The Nubians of that time attended conferences but did not get much involved in street activism. But, Ms. Othman told the AP, her generation has a “new spirit.” However, the government is not allowing that new spirit to be expressed publicly. A protest involving a convoy of vehicles in 2016 was intercepted by officials and forced to turn back. The protest in September 2017 was broken up by the security forces and the protesters were arrested.

The AP article describes the growing Nubian demands in terms of their determination to reclaim their identity, their language, and their lands. Their right to resettle along the Nile was affirmed by the current constitution of Egypt, approved in 2014. It also recognized the Nubians as an ethnic minority in the nation. But the problem with the state recognizing the rights of the Nubians is that the elites running Egypt, led by President el-Sissi, seem to feel that the national stability is threatened by the expressions of those minority rights.

This excellent overview of the current situation among the Nubians could have been improved by referring readers to the traditional peacefulness of the people in their villages of Old Nubia, with references to some of the classic ethnographies such as the book by Robert A. Fernea (1973), Nubians in Egypt: Peaceful People.

 

Fifteen Yanadi workers were killed by an explosion at an illegal fireworks manufacturing facility in a Nellore suburb on December 31, 2016, exposing to the public the deplorable working conditions that they endure. The story was widely reported in the Indian press in early January 2017.

A firecracker roll containing 10,000 firecrackers
A firecracker roll containing 10,000 firecrackers (Photo by Zoravar (talk) in Wikipedia, Creative Commons license)

A number of people from the Challa Yanadi, a lower-caste division of the Yanadi society, were employed as workers in one of the fireworks manufacturing factories in Porlukatta, a community next to the city of Nellore, in India’s Andhra Pradesh. A fire broke out, probably among piles of dangerous, highly flammable, chemicals, spread into a major storage area for firecrackers, and they suddenly exploded. Three Yanadi workers died immediately and many were seriously burned. Over the course of the following days, 12 more were reported to have died in hospitals in the city.

The Hindu, a widely respected Indian newspaper, published an update last week about the tragedy. The reporter, Sundaram Morali, is at first greeted silently when he enters one of the factories in Porlukatta but the workers gradually open up to him. One group tells him that only three workers had died in the explosion over 18 months earlier. A worker bearing scars from his burns mentions, as he hurries to complete an order for fireworks for a celebration at a home in the Magunta Layout, a section of Nellore, how their efforts to save injured co-workers last year were futile.

Fireworks for the Diwali Festival in Chennai
Fireworks during the Diwali Festival in Chennai (Photo by Sriram Jagannathan in Wikimedia, Creative Commons license)

The Yanadi tell the reporter that they are well aware of the risks in making the explosives. But “what else … can [we] do for a living now?” they ask rhetorically. The workers used to subsist on their fishing in the river but it no longer flows regularly. Almost all the bodies of water in the city have vanished due to climate change, another worker says while he sits in the midst of piles of chemicals.

The Yanadi workers earn between 300 and 400 Indian rupees (U.S. $3.40 to $5.80) per day. That includes their pay for overtime work, one worker explains as he coughs from the chronic respiratory illnesses that plague many of them. They are exposed to such hazardous chemicals as potassium nitrate, sulphur nitrate, nitrogen dioxide, magnesium, and others.

One worker explains to The Hindu that they get the chemicals from Tamil Nadu, the state to the south of Andhra Pradesh. Another talks about popular occasions when Indians use fireworks to celebrate, such as Diwali, weddings, and birthdays. He talks while mixing chemicals, though without using hand gloves or any other safety devices.

Though Mr. Morali doesn’t say so, to a reader who is far from South India it sounds as if the promises by politicians in January 2017 to improve conditions for the Challa Yanadi fireworks workers have not been carried out.

 

National Public Radio broadcast a feature last week about the cooperation between a Hutterite colony in Montana and a dude ranch/resort complex located five hours away. The complex, called The Resort at Paws Up, has a long tradition of friendly cooperation with the Cool Spring Hutterite Colony that predates some of its present employees.

Some Hutterites observing nature in the Bitterroots and National Bison Range of Montana
Some Hutterites observing nature in the Bitterroots and the National Bison Range of Montana (Photo by Eric Gross in Flickr, Creative Commons license)

The article on the NPR website provides some useful information about the Hutterites as well an explanation about the cooperative project with the resort. By way of background, the reporter explains to the listeners that the Hutterites, much like the Amish and the Mennonites, live by the principle of nonresistance, the belief that one must not resist authorities, even when their demands are unjust. The central values of the Hutterites, who live in colonies of less than 150 people on the prairies of western Canada and the United States, focus on hard work as well as their faith and their families.

Jake Waldner, a Hutterite man from the Cool Spring Colony, describes to the reporter in the course of their conversation the fallacies in a National Geographic program about the Hutterites that it produced and broadcast in 2012. The special, mostly filmed at the King Colony just west of Lewistown, Montana, was widely criticized at the time by the Hutterites and by other authorities (see news stories in June and August 2012).

Two Hutterite women at the King Colony in Montana who host overnight visitors, such as the photographer who noted that they were “very friendly and welcoming”
Two Hutterite women at the King Colony in Montana who host overnight visitors, such as the photographer who noted that they were “very friendly and welcoming” (Photo by Matt Green on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

To judge by Mr. Waldner’s comments to NPR, it still rankles. The program, “American Colony: Meet the Hutterites,” wasn’t very accurate, he says. It avoided mentioning the importance of religion to the Hutterites—it presented “such a false reality,” in his opinion. It showed a number of inaccurate situations and activities at the King Colony that the Hutterites simply don’t do. There was “a lot of under-the-table stuff that was acted out and not even close to [how] real Hutterites live,” Waldner tells the reporter.

Waldner is the chicken boss at the Cool Spring Colony, which raises 8,000 chickens, 1,000 turkeys and 1,000 ducks annually. The birds are raised free-range, without antibiotics or hormones, and they are fed wheat and barley that are grown on the 9,600-acre property. Once they are processed, Waldner delivers them to local stores, farm markets, and businesses such as Paws Up.  He sometimes leaves the colony at 2 a.m. in order to deliver the meat to customers early in the morning.

Waldner met the executive chef at Paws Up 14 years ago at a weekly farm market in Missoula, Montana. He explains that the chef invited him to stop over to the resort and see how they use chickens. “From that day we clicked, and a great relationship began,” he says. The colony still supplies the birds for the resort, an arrangement that was sealed on a handshake deal between the two men. A new executive chef at the resort, Sunny Jin, was willing to continue the relationship, celebrated recently with the reporter present by a dessert for the kitchen crew of strawberry-rhubarb pie brought by Waldner from the colony. “When I came on board, I realized there was a strong partnership here with the Hutterites that was more based on friendship and bartering than monetary gain,” Jin tells NPR.

A corruption scandal in the traditional Fipa territory recently resulted in disciplinary action being taken against numerous officials. Dr. Hamisi Kigwangalla, Minister for Natural Resources and Tourism of Tanzania, suspended 27 game rangers and officers after hearing complaints at a village meeting.

Hamisi Kigwanggalla, Minister of Natural Resources and Tourism for Tanzania
Hamisi Kigwanggalla, Minister of Natural Resources and Tourism for Tanzania (Photo by Dr. Kigwangalla in Wikimedia, Creative Commons license)

According to a report on July 9 in a Tanzanian news service, Kigwangalla suspended Lackson Mwamezi, the acting manager of the Uwanda Forest, after attending a public rally at Kilyamatundu village. The villagers accused the officials and game rangers of requiring bribes from owners of livestock for permission to graze their animals in the forest. He was told that the rangers and officials were requiring payments of 6 to 7 million Tanzanian shillings (U.S. $2,600 – $3,000) for permission to graze their cattle in the forest lands. Fishermen who wanted to use illegal fishing gear in the Rukwa River had to bribe the officers 100,000 shillings ($44) to do so.

The news report named one of the accusers. Shija Imeli alleged that the game rangers had required a payment of 6,000,000 shillings from him so he could graze his cattle in the forest lands for 5 months. He said that he had paid 5,800,000 but the rangers confiscated his cattle until he had paid the additional 200,000 they required.

Results of overgrazing in the Rukwa plains on the southeastern side of the lake
Results of overgrazing in the plains on the southeastern side of Lake Rukwa (Photo by Lichinga in Wikimedia, Creative Commons license)

Kigwangalla gave the villagers 30 days to remove their cattle from the forest. He directed the government’s Prevention and Combating of Corruption Bureau to investigate the allegations of the villagers. Pending the results of that investigation, he asked the director of the Tanzania Wildlife Management Authority, Dr. James Walkaibara, to recruit new game rangers.

A story in the same news source three days earlier provided more background information. Evidently, Dr. Kigwangalla had received a report from the Sumbawanga District Commissioner, Khalfani Haule, that the number of cattle grazing in the Uwanda Forest had significantly increased to at least 12,000 head. Kigwangalla had ordered the suspension of the forest reserve manager for the Sumbawanga District, Mark Chuwa, as a result. The minister was disappointed that local forest officials had failed to find an effective solution to the problem of excessive grazing in the forest lands.

 

A selfless 63-year old man from a rural village in the Jashpur District of Chhattisgarh has devoted his life to promoting the welfare of the Birhor people. The Hitavada, an English-language daily newspaper from Central India, published an account on July 6th of the work of Jageshwar Ram Yadav, who was recently recognized by the Chhattisgarh state government with its Shaheed Veer Narayan Singh Award for his efforts on behalf of the Birhor. It is the premier recognition by the state for achievements in tribal development and protection.

Birhor woman with children
Birhor woman with children (Screen capture from the video “Birhor—a Tribe Displaced for Nothing” by VideoVolunteers on YouTube, Creative Commons license).

Yadav was raised in the village of Bhitghara, in the Bagicha Block of Jashpur District and he became attracted as a child to a nearby Birhor group. He spent a lot of his time during his childhood with the Birhor, frequently inquiring about them from his parents, though they never really understood his feelings for the tribal people. In fact, other members of his village also disapproved of his attachment to the Birhor and threatened to boycott him because of his growing interest in them.

After he completed his 10th grade examinations, he decided to not pursue any further education and to devote his life to promoting the welfare of the Birhor. Some years later, around the age of 25, Yadav left his village and moved into the forest to live with them. He told the newspaper that his experiences were not easy. The Birhor people didn’t know who he was or what motivated him, so they were apprehensive. “They thought that I have come to hypnotize them for human-sacrifice,” he told the reporter.

A Birhor man making a rope
A Birhor man making a rope (Screen capture from the video “Birhor—A tribe displaced for nothing,” by VideoVolunteers on YouTube, Creative Commons license)

But they slowly grew to trust him as he learned to speak their language, called “Birhoduk” in this account. His travels expanded and he visited Birhor communities more widely across Chhattisgarh, in the Korba, Bilaspur and Raigarh districts. He explained that he often walked 50 km from one community to the next through the forests. Since most of the Birhor males were out hunting during the daytime, he usually had to wait until evening to talk with them.

He would stay with them in their forest huts, learning how they fabricated ropes out of the fibers of forest vines which they sold in nearby town markets. He would get the names of their friends and relatives in other settlements which he would then visit. He bragged that he had met every Birhor in the state.

A dholak
A dholak (photo by adil113 on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

He explained to the reporter that the Birhor were a landless, nomadic people who traditionally subsisted on their hunting and gathering. They particularly thrived on the monkeys they killed, eating the meat and selling the skins, which were used in the construction of musical instruments such as the dholak, a hand-held, two-headed drum. He said that they had a high rate of infant mortality, were usually drunk, and that their standard of living was “pathetic.”

Yadav started campaigning for more government assistance for the Birhor. He wrote to officials, including then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, personally lobbied with members of parliament and the state legislative assembly, and visited bureaucrats in a variety of government departments. He campaigned for vaccinations, better sanitation, and help with their addictions. He appealed for support for agricultural equipment and oxen so he could persuade some of them to settle into agricultural life.

He lobbied for health improvements for the Birhor as well as support for their education. He urged government agencies to provide a job for any Birhor person who completes a class 8 education. His efforts paid off when the government finally designated the Birhor as a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG), which enabled them to take advantage of a number of government welfare programs.

As a result of his efforts, numerous schools have opened in Chhattisgarh for Birhor children. Most of the Birhor in the state are now engaged in agricultural pursuits and their education, health, and standard of living have improved. The journalist for The Hitavada concludes, the “majority of them have also shunned their age-old practice of eating monkey’s meat.”

 

His Holiness the Dalai Lama flew to Leh on July 3rd in order to spend 19 days in Ladakh, which included a celebration of his 83rd birthday on Friday the 6th. Four different local news sources covered the story—The Statesman, The Kashmir Monitor, Phayul.com, and Scoop News—emphasizing in different ways the mutual respect that the Ladakhi people have for the Buddhist leader and that he has for them.

The visit of the Dalai Lama to Leh in July 2012
The visit of the Dalai Lama to Leh in July 2012 (Photo by Andrea Schieber in Flickr, Creative Commons license)

According to the press reports, thousands lined the road from the airport to his official residence in Leh, the Shewatsel Phodrang, welcoming him with flowers and adornments. The Ladakhi men, women and children showed their respect for him by wearing their best clothing and carrying flowers, incense, and khataks, the ceremonial scarves that are traditionally given to lamas to show love and recognition to them. Many tourists were also in the crowds.

For his part, the Dalai Lama told a group of religious and community leaders at his residence about his joy at being able to visit Ladakh once again. He thanked the rinpoches, monks, nuns, and lay people, telling them that he appreciated their show of love and respect. He told his listeners that, along with material development, people need to develop the qualities of love, kindness, peace, forgiveness and compassion. All the religions of the world should develop such values, His Holiness said.

The Dalai Lama visiting Leh in 2014
The Dalai Lama visiting Leh in 2014 (Photo by Tzafrirt1 in Wikimedia, Creative Commons license)

He spoke about a recent conference in Delhi of the Indian Himalayan Buddhist communities, which Buddhist scholars from across India attended. He commended the decision of the Buddhist leaders at the conference to convert monasteries into learning centers. The shift of secular society from a feudal model into a democratic one should inspire the monastic system to make similar progressive changes. The “feudal system garners hate and violence, while democracy gives [the] right to all for developing a peaceful environment,” His Holiness added.

The Dalai Lama is widely loved and respected by the Muslim residents of Ladakh as well as by the Buddhists. After the birthday celebrations at his residence on the 6th, he planned to give teachings on Shantideva’s A Guide to the Bodhisatva’s Way of Life from July 10 to 12. From July 18 to 20, he will participate in the Yarcho Chenmo, the Summer Buddhist Council for philosophical debates and discussions, held annually at the Samstanling Gonpa Sumoor in Nubra. He will also do some teaching at the teaching ground of the Shewatsel in Leh and in Nubra while he is there.

Donald Kraybill, who is undoubtedly the leading authority on Amish life, has just written another book on his favorite subject. Last week, LancasterOnline reviewed his new work, Simply Amish, which was published by Herald Press on June 26.

It is a popularly-written, slender book of only 64 pages that is designed to answer questions about the Amish posed by visitors to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania—as well as those asked by the local “English.” Kraybill has retired from his teaching position at Elizabethtown College in the county but he still has the title Senior Fellow Emeritus at the Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies on the campus. “I have a lot of neighbors here in Elizabethtown who ask me a lot of interesting questions about the Amish that they really don’t know,” Kraybill tells LancasterOnline. So he designed his latest book to answer those questions.

One of the major topics of the book is the fact that the different dimensions of Amish life tend to be integrated into their religious life. In contrast, life for modern people in Lancaster County is specialized. Kraybill explains that non-Amish modern individuals have their families, their work, their community, their athletics, and so on. The Amish have their church. “You have this much stronger sense of integration of all of the dimensions of life in the Amish community,” he adds.

Donald Kraybill
Donald Kraybill (Photo by Dave Bonta)

Quoting Karen Johnson-Weiner, another Elizabethtown professor and also an authority on the Amish, Kraybill concludes that the “Amish people are always in church.” But he says that avoiding automobiles and continuing to emphasize their horse and buggy culture remains the defining characteristic of membership in Amish society. However, he says, the colors of the buggies vary—the ones in Lancaster County are gray while those in Holmes County, Ohio, are black.

Despite the fact that he has retired, Kraybill keeps busy. He edits the works of other scholars, continues doing research, and is assembling his papers for the Elizabethtown College archives. He expresses pleasure that he now can attended meetings and lectures if he feels like it. He says it is a privilege and a nice bonus of being retired, a sentiment that any academic can easily understand.

An interesting drama that played out last week in a courtroom in Papeete, the capital of French Polynesia, evidently captured the attention and sympathies of the Tahitians. A magistrate agreed with the pleas of two homeless Tahitian people that they had the right to keep their dogs with them, despite the fact that they had no permanent addresses.

A police officer in Papeete writing out a ticket
A police officer in Papeete writing out a ticket (Photo by John Abel on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

One of the major Tahitian news sources reported that Ms. Angeline Tevaria and another person named Urarii Tautu witnessed Papeete municipal police officers capturing their five dogs during the night of June 19. A local radio station provided supporting details. The attorney for the town, Robin Quinquis, told the court that the justification for seizing the dogs was that they represented potential risks to public safety, hygiene, and health. The dogs were taken to the public pound and would have been euthanized after eight days, according to municipal policies, if no one claimed them. Ms. Tevaria decided to appeal.

She engaged an attorney, Annick Allain-Sacault, to represent her in the court hearing. Ms. Allain-Sacault denied the claim by the town that the dogs represented a health risk. They are in good health, she told the court, showing medical certificates to support her argument. So far as being potentially dangerous, she denied that too. They were in the public accommodation with their owners when they were seized. She argued that they were taken solely because their owners are homeless. The authorities believed that they could deny people their rights because of their homelessness.

A dog on Moorea, French Polynesia
A dog on Moorea, French Polynesia (Photo by pablo-marx on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

The attorney for the municipality argued that the decision by the mayor, Michel Buillard, was not made on whim but for a real cause. Urarii Tautu, the other homeless person, had allegedly encouraged his two dogs to attack a sheriff back in January. The Deputy Chief of the Municipal Police also spoke at the hearing, claiming to have witnessed “aggressive begging” by the two homeless people with their dogs.

Another news service in French Polynesia added that Angeline Tevaria is 31 years old and she has been homeless for five years. She lives in a shelter in Papeete and is 50 percent physically disabled. Her dogs thus serve as essential companions for her.

The judge heard the case Tuesday morning, June 26, and by 3:00 in the afternoon had reached a decision: the court agreed with the arguments of the two homeless people, finding that the town had not shown any evidence that their dogs were wandering or dangerous. Furthermore, there was no evidence that traders in Papeete were complaining about the five dogs, contrary to the allegations of the mayor. Also, there was no proof that the dogs were sick or abused. The judge ordered the authorities in Papeete to return the dogs to their two owners or to one of the animal welfare associations in town within 24 hours. The news reports indicated that the Tahitian people were fascinated by the drama.

The well-known Zapotec rug weaver Pastora Gutierrez Reyes made the news again last week, this time in a New York Times feature. Ms. Gutierrez, a leader for women’s rights in the town of Teotitlán del Valle, in Mexico’s Oaxaca State, was described in Lynn Stephen’s book Zapotec Women (2005) and more recently in a Truthout story.

Pastora Gutierrez Reyes (left) and her sister Silvia hold up a couple of their rugs to show off the traditional Zapotec designs
Pastora Gutierrez Reyes (left) and her sister Silvia hold up a couple of their rugs to show off the traditional Zapotec designs (All images are screenshots from the video “Vida Nueva (“New Life”) Cooperative at the International Folk Art Market” by Fierce Kitty Media on Vimeo, Creative Commons license)

The Times reporter, Deborah Needleman, relates how Ms. Gutierrez welcomed her into her home while she was making red dye out of pulverized cochineal, an insect. The 46-year-old weaver tells her that the recipes she uses for her dyes all came from her great-grandmother. She weaves colorful rugs with patterns that capture the traditions of Zapotec life and the surrounding natural world.

Gutierrez then provides the reporter with some of her background. About 20 years ago, she and the other women of Teotitlán were being exploited by middlemen in the village of about 5,500 people. Many of the men in Teotitlán, located about 12 miles east of the city of Oaxaca, had left for the United States for work and the middlemen were exploiting the women and cheating them out of their earnings from the rugs they made. They were paying the women less than their costs.

Led by Gutierrez and some others, the women tried making other craft products than rugs to sell but the middlemen insisted they had to continue making just rugs for them. So the women started working for the middlemen for a week, then for themselves the next. In response, the men tried visiting the women in their homes at night.

Pastora Gutierrez Reyes
Pastora Gutierrez Reyes

Gutierrez heard about a government scheme that would grant funds to rural Mexican women so she decided to apply. She had not realized the corruption involved—grantees had to attend political rallies for the ruling party. In any case, they got the grant, which allowed them to purchase wool, fabricate rugs, and sell them from their homes. But the middlemen continued to threaten them so they started traveling every week to Mexico City markets, over 200 miles away, in order to avoid undercutting their adversaries.

Their journeys to the capital city caused them to be ostracized in Teotitlán. To make matters worse, they discovered that the grant had in fact been a loan which they were unable to repay. They were shunned in their own village until they sold their livestock and jewelry and were able to repay the loan. And to make matters worse, they still were required to attend the political rallies.

The two sisters, Pastora Gutierrez Reyes (left) and Silvia Gutierrez Reyes
The two sisters, Pastora Gutierrez Reyes (left) and Silvia Gutierrez Reyes

But a woman named Flor Cervantes, who worked for a nonprofit organization, came into the village about 10 years ago and brought new ways of looking at things. A younger sister, Silvia Gutierrez Reyes, interrupts the story to show Ms. Needleman some old family photos. It becomes clear from the conversation among the three women that until the visits with Ms. Cervantes had started, even the facts of a woman’s reproductive organs were unknown to the ladies of Teotitlán.

Cervantes worked to slowly build the self-esteem, knowledge and confidence of the Teotitlán women, who also gained a lot of information from her about domestic violence. The reporter writes that she had a hard time reconciling the confident leader of the women in today’s Teotitlán with the stories by the same individual who was feeling completely powerless just 10 years ago.

The members of Vida Nueva
The members of Vida Nueva

Vida Nueva, the cooperative that Ms. Gutierrez founded, has between 13 and 20 women members. Once it received official approval, it was able to sell products outside Mexico. The members of the cooperative initiate different programs every year, each woman donating profits of her own choosing for the efforts. At one point, the U.N. granted them the funds to purchase new looms.

With all the obvious successes and profits from their creative work, the reporter asks how the men in Teotitlán treat her now. Ms. Gutierrez replies that the men today are showing respect for her. And she says there is less machismo in the village, at least toward herself. Vida Nueva spearheaded a recycling system for the village, founded an eldercare program, and initiated a project to reforest communal lands. And last year she became the first woman to take a position in the village assembly, so things are changing slowly.

It is a fight for the women, it is very important
It is a fight for the women, it is very important

“Just a year before,” she told the Times, “no one wanted a woman to have a position.” The men respect the way she has varied the offerings of the cooperative—they diversified from just rugs to also making pillow cases, totes, and bags. The reporter indicates that the improvements the women have brought to Teotitlán have been based on their ethic of welcoming changes only when the entire community benefits, a basic value of the Zapotec.